site stats

Reconsider with major revisions

WebbEditor’s Decision: Reconsider after major revisions (16 March 2024) by James Dyke We agree that the increased length of the paper detracts from its readability. We note that the increased length resulted from a very long list of requested explanations and clarifications by … Webb8 jan. 2014 · First, we would like to say thank you to the reviewers for the useful comments to improve the paper. We have addressed all the comments as explained below. REVIEWER 1. “Section 3 is too long”. We have addressed this comment by deleting a few lines at the end of the second paragraph that were not necessary for understanding the algorithm.

别被论文大修吓到！除了“reject”其他都算好消息 - 知乎

Webb9 dec. 2024 · There are of course some problems, which are genuinely difficult to solve. 3a) your paper nonetheless has important results: then highlight that further research is necessary and your result is a ... WebbEditor’s Decision: Reconsider after major revisions (16 March 2024) by James Dyke We agree that the increased length of the paper detracts from its readability. We note that … city of rockingham suburbs https://mcpacific.net

Associate Editor Decision: Reconsider after major revisions

Webb9 jan. 2024 · Often the peer review process progresses smoothly through the steps: A new manuscript is submitted; appropriate reviewers are identified, invited and promptly accept; they provide a report that arrives on time recommending major revisions; the authors thoughtfully revise their manuscript to the satisfaction of the reviewers so that the … http://winet.ece.ufl.edu/tvt/associateeditors/majorrevisions.html WebbAssociate Editor Decision: Reconsider after major revisions (02 Jul 2024) by Jens-Arne Subke Comments to the Author: Dear Drs Zha and Zhuang, Thank you for addressing referees concerns over the manuscript. I have reviewed your changes and have reason to request further changes before I’m able to finally accept this manuscript for publication. city of rockingham pet registration

Does "minor revision" mean "accepted with minor revision"?

Category:Reconsider Definition & Meaning Dictionary.com

Tags:Reconsider with major revisions

Reconsider with major revisions

Editor Initial Decision: Reconsider after major revisions Reply

Webb21 apr. 2024 · When making major revisions, we always take the time to comment/explain why we have removed or rebuilt that section. Of course, we do not succeed to eliminate all darlings every single time and sometimes darlings walk right back where we removed them from. That’s ok too.

Reconsider with major revisions

Did you know?

WebbReconsider definition, to consider again, especially with a view to change of decision or action: to reconsider a refusal. See more. WebbEditor Initial Decision: Reconsider after major revisions (20 Oct 2014) by Dr. Jim Freer: Comments to the Author Editor Comment First I thank the reviewers and the author for their very useful correspondence on this paper. I believe the editors have made some clear points that need to be addressed in

http://muchong.com/t-14651511-1-pid-9 Webb15 juni 2024 · 收到Major Revision就说明审稿人对你的paper是认可的，认为你的内容确实有contribution。除此之外，审稿人一般会给你若干条意见，可以根据每条意见进行修改。 …

Webb所谓大修（major revision）是相对于小修（minor revision）而言的。 这两者的差别主要体现在修改幅度以及修改后的处理流程上。 二、修改注意事项 要知道，大修的稿件并不能 … Webb投必得写作专栏的“SCI投稿系列”已经推出了一篇，即“SCI文章提交后各状态解析—论文投稿新手必备”。 今天推出第二篇： 关于Major Revision，你应该知道的那些事。 投稿过程中，估计最常见的遭遇是reject。而第二常见的，应该是major revision（应该还包括reject and resubmit，这个内容稍后会谈到）。

Webb1. No, minor revision doesn't mean accepted with minor revisions. Strictly speaking, for truly minor revisions, it's possible that the editor accepts your paper and leaves you to …

WebbThe Decision to Reconsider, Major Revisions (Revise and Resubmit) It is important to distinguish between papers that are rejected (and which, if submitted again after … city of rockingham waste collectionWebb1,771 人 赞同了该文章. 上周有个小伙伴问有没有大修意见（Major Revision）的模板，我的第一反应是大修哪还有什么模板啊，就是一条一条的回复审稿人的修改建议啊。. 不过后来翻了翻自己以前写的回复信，发现多多少少还是有一定模板性的，尤其是对于第一次 ... city of rockingham wasteWebbmajor revisions (在本例中我们收到的决定) reject （显然是你希望避免的决定） 正如你所看到的，编辑最有可能在初步审查后给你回信并建议你的论文需要进行“小修”或“大修”。 小 … city of rockingham taxesWebb29 sep. 2014 · Reject: This is an outright rejection decision, and in most cases, the journal will not publish the paper or reconsider it even if the author makes major revisions. The … do sea otters lay eggsWebb4 aug. 2024 · Reviewer/Editor: accept (occasionally: reject) In case of rejection based on a single reviewer's recommendation, the editor usually consults another reviewer. In this … city of rockingham verge collection dateshttp://winet.ece.ufl.edu/tvt/associateeditors/majorrevisions.html#:~:text=In%20the%20%22reconsider%20after%20major%20revision%22%20case%2C%20an,be%20revised%20taking%20into%20account%20the%20comments%20provided. city of rockingham tax billWebb20 okt. 2015 · Reject and Resubmit (or revise and resubmit) (hereafter, R&R) = your article has been rejected. Major revision = your article is in a kind of limbo state where it is neither accepted as is nor rejected but rather held unto the revisions come in. R&R = you have no reason to expect the same reviewers. city of rockingham verge pick up